Skip to content

Advice & regulation

Whose interests come first? Why independence from product manufacturers matters

. Tilbrook Advice Team. 2 min read

When an adviser is not tied to the products they recommend, the conversation can begin with your goals rather than a shelf of options. Here is why that structural independence matters.

Financial advice is built on trust. Clients share their circumstances, their worries and their hopes, and in return they expect advice that serves their interests. One of the most important, and least visible, factors in whether that expectation is met is the adviser’s relationship with the companies that make financial products.

What vertical integration means

In parts of the financial services industry, the same group may manufacture investment products, operate platforms and employ or license the advisers who recommend them. This is often called vertical integration. It is legal and common, and many people within such groups work diligently for their clients.

The difficulty is structural. When an organisation earns revenue from the products its advisers recommend, there is an inherent tension between the interests of the business and those of the client. Regulators have long recognised this, and Australian law requires advisers to act in the best interests of their clients and to prioritise those interests when conflicts arise. Rules are an important safeguard. But a structure that minimises the conflict in the first place offers a different kind of assurance.

Rules are an important safeguard. But a structure that minimises the conflict in the first place offers a different kind of assurance.

What independence makes possible

An adviser who is not owned by, or financially tied to, a product manufacturer can approach each decision from a different starting point. The question becomes what a client needs, not which of a limited set of in-house products fits best. In practice, independence tends to support:

  • A broader field of view. Investment options can be assessed on their merits across the market rather than from an approved list shaped by commercial relationships.
  • Clearer reasons for every recommendation. Without a product to place, advice can focus on strategy, structure and behaviour, areas that often matter more than product selection.
  • Freedom to recommend doing less. Sometimes the best advice is to keep things simple, hold cash for a purpose, or leave a portfolio unchanged. Independence removes the pressure to transact.
  • Transparent costs. When the adviser is paid by the client, the fee can be stated plainly, and clients can judge its value directly.

Questions to ask any adviser

Whatever adviser you choose, it is reasonable to ask how they are structured and paid. Their Financial Services Guide should explain this, but a direct conversation is often more revealing:

  • Who owns your business, and does that owner issue or promote any financial products?
  • How are you paid, and do you receive any payment from product providers?
  • How do you select and review the investments you recommend?
  • What conflicts of interest exist, and how do you manage them?

Good advisers welcome these questions. Clear, direct answers are a useful sign of how the relationship will work over time.

Independence as a foundation

For families, founders and foundations, the decisions at stake are often complex and long-lived. They involve trusts and companies, philanthropy, succession and the investment of capital that may need to serve more than one generation. In that context, knowing that the advice you receive is aligned with your interests from the ground up is not a detail. It is the foundation on which every other part of the relationship rests.

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).

Latest news

Firm news

Introducing The Tilbrook Brief

The Tilbrook Brief is our new periodic newsletter, bringing together our insights on wealth, family and giving. Subscribe through the Newsletter page on our website.

, 2 min read

Markets & outlook

The year ahead: six themes we are watching in 2027

Rather than forecasts, we offer a set of themes likely to shape conversations about wealth in 2027, from the path of inflation to private markets, technology and the transfer of wealth between generations.

, 2 min read

Firm news

Our home in Brisbane: 80 Petrie Terrace

Our office at 80 Petrie Terrace in Brisbane City is the base from which we serve clients across Queensland and around Australia, in person or online.

, 2 min read