Skip to content

Markets & outlook

Holding steady: a behavioural lens on market volatility

. Tilbrook Investment Team. 2 min read

Volatility tests our instincts as much as our portfolios. Understanding the biases that surface in turbulent markets can help investors respond with intention rather than reaction.

Markets rise and fall. Most investors know this in principle, and most can recall periods when sharp declines were followed, sometimes surprisingly quickly, by recovery. Yet when volatility arrives, that knowledge can feel distant. The urge to act, to do something, is powerful.

Behavioural finance offers a useful way to understand why. Our decisions are shaped by mental shortcuts that served us well in everyday life but can work against us when it comes to long-term investing.

The biases that surface in turbulent markets

  • Loss aversion: losses tend to feel more painful than equivalent gains feel pleasant. A falling portfolio can provoke a response out of proportion to its effect on long-term goals.
  • Recency bias: we give too much weight to what has just happened and assume it will continue, whether the recent trend is up or down.
  • Herding: when others appear to be selling, joining them feels safer than standing apart, even when the original reasons for an investment remain intact.
  • Overconfidence: after a period of good returns, we may overestimate our ability to time the market, or underestimate how much risk we are carrying.
  • Checking too often: frequent monitoring makes short-term swings more visible and more emotionally charged, which can prompt unnecessary changes.

None of these biases reflect a lack of intelligence. They are human. The aim is not to eliminate them but to build a process that limits how much they influence important decisions.

The cost of stepping out

One of the hardest aspects of reacting to volatility is that selling requires two correct decisions: when to get out and when to get back in. Some of the strongest days in markets have historically occurred close to some of the weakest, so investors who step aside during a downturn risk missing part of the recovery. Even a well-intentioned move to safety can permanently lower the long-term path of a portfolio.

Selling in a downturn requires two correct decisions: when to get out and when to get back in.

Building a portfolio you can live with

The most effective defence against reactive decisions is usually made well before volatility arrives. A few habits tend to help:

  • Match assets to purpose. Money needed in the near term is best held in assets that will not be forced into a sale at a poor time, leaving long-term assets free to ride out cycles.
  • Agree a plan in calm conditions. A written strategy, including how and when the portfolio will be rebalanced, gives a reference point when emotions run high.
  • Rebalance with discipline. Periodically returning to target weights means trimming what has risen and adding to what has fallen, which runs counter to instinct in a helpful way.
  • Know your tolerance honestly. A portfolio that is theoretically optimal but impossible to hold through a downturn may serve you worse than a more moderate one you can stick with.
  • Talk it through. A conversation with a trusted adviser can create the pause needed between feeling and acting.

For families, volatility can also be a valuable teaching moment. Explaining to the next generation why the plan is unchanged, and how it was designed with turbulence in mind, builds understanding that will outlast any single market event.

Volatility is the price of admission for long-term growth assets. Paying it calmly, within a plan built for the purpose, is one of the most valuable things an investor can do.

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).

Latest news

Firm news

Introducing The Tilbrook Brief

The Tilbrook Brief is our new periodic newsletter, bringing together our insights on wealth, family and giving. Subscribe through the Newsletter page on our website.

, 2 min read

Markets & outlook

The year ahead: six themes we are watching in 2027

Rather than forecasts, we offer a set of themes likely to shape conversations about wealth in 2027, from the path of inflation to private markets, technology and the transfer of wealth between generations.

, 2 min read

Firm news

Our home in Brisbane: 80 Petrie Terrace

Our office at 80 Petrie Terrace in Brisbane City is the base from which we serve clients across Queensland and around Australia, in person or online.

, 2 min read