Skip to content

Responsible investing

Impact Investing: Measuring What Matters

. Tilbrook Investment Team. 4 min read

Impact investing promises measurable social and environmental outcomes alongside financial returns. Understanding how impact is defined, measured and reported is essential to making that promise meaningful.

Impact investing has moved from the margins of the investment world towards the mainstream. For families, foundations and not-for-profits, it offers a way to put capital to work in pursuit of social and environmental outcomes while also seeking a financial return. Affordable housing, renewable energy, community health services and social enterprises are among the many areas where impact capital is now active.

What distinguishes impact investing from other forms of responsible investment is intentionality and measurement. An impact investor sets out deliberately to contribute to a specific positive outcome, and seeks evidence that it is being achieved. That second element, measurement, is where much of the real work lies.

Why measurement matters

Without measurement, impact is simply a claim. Investors cannot know whether their capital is achieving what they intended, managers cannot learn and improve, and the broader market cannot distinguish genuine impact from marketing. Measurement also brings accountability, both to the investor and to the communities and environments the investment is meant to benefit.

That said, measuring impact is inherently more complex than measuring financial performance. Social and environmental outcomes take time to emerge, are influenced by many factors and do not reduce neatly to a single number. A thoughtful approach acknowledges these limitations rather than pretending to a precision that does not exist.

Without measurement, impact is simply a claim.

Defining impact before measuring it

Good measurement begins with clarity about what change the investment is meant to produce. Many impact investors use a theory of change, a simple description of how an investment's activities are expected to lead to outcomes and, ultimately, broader impact.

  • Inputs: the capital and other resources provided.
  • Activities: what the investee organisation does with those resources.
  • Outputs: the direct, countable products of those activities, such as homes built or patients treated.
  • Outcomes: the changes experienced by people or the environment as a result, such as improved housing stability or health.
  • Impact: the longer-term, broader change to which the outcomes contribute.

A common pitfall is to report outputs as if they were outcomes. Counting the number of people who attend a program is useful, but it does not tell us whether their lives have improved as a result. Stronger impact measurement makes a genuine effort to capture outcomes, even where that is harder.

Key questions for assessing impact

A widely used way of thinking about impact considers several dimensions. Investors evaluating an opportunity or reviewing an existing holding might ask:

  • What outcome is being pursued, and how important is it to the people or environment affected?
  • Who experiences the outcome, and how underserved are they?
  • How much change occurs, for how many, and for how long?
  • Contribution: would this outcome have occurred anyway without this investment?
  • Risk: what is the likelihood that the expected impact does not eventuate, and what could cause that?

The contribution question is particularly important and often overlooked. If an investment funds an outcome that would have happened regardless, its additional impact may be limited, even if the outcome itself is valuable.

Frameworks and standards

A range of frameworks, metrics catalogues and reporting standards have been developed to bring greater consistency to impact measurement. Many investors also map their investments to the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals as a shared reference point. These tools are valuable for comparability and discipline, but they work best as aids to judgement rather than substitutes for it.

Investors should be cautious about frameworks being applied superficially, for example by tagging an investment to a goal without evidence of a meaningful connection. The question should always return to whether there is a credible link between the investment and the outcomes claimed.

Practical considerations for investors

Measurement should be proportionate. Smaller investments or early-stage enterprises may not have the resources for extensive evaluation, and imposing heavy reporting requirements can divert effort from the work itself. A pragmatic approach agrees on a small number of meaningful indicators that are genuinely useful to both investor and investee.

  • Agree on impact objectives and key indicators at the outset, alongside financial terms.
  • Ask how data will be collected, how often, and how its reliability will be tested.
  • Look for reporting that includes challenges and setbacks, not only successes.
  • Consider whether the voices of affected communities are reflected in how impact is assessed.
  • Review impact performance with the same regularity and seriousness as financial performance.

Balancing impact and financial objectives

Impact investments vary widely in their financial characteristics. Some seek returns comparable to conventional investments; others accept a lower or more uncertain return in exchange for deeper impact. Many are less liquid than listed investments, and some carry risks specific to their sectors or structures.

For foundations and not-for-profits, it is important to be clear about where an impact investment sits within the overall portfolio and its objectives. Some organisations treat certain impact investments as part of their investment portfolio, held to financial standards; others treat them as an extension of their grant-making, where mission is the primary objective. Both approaches can be legitimate, but the distinction should be explicit and reflected in governance and reporting.

Impact investing offers a powerful way to bring capital and purpose together. Its credibility, and ultimately its effectiveness, depends on the willingness of investors to ask hard questions, measure honestly and keep learning about what genuinely matters.

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on it, consider its appropriateness to your circumstances and, where relevant, read the Financial Services Guide and any product disclosure document. Tilbrook Securities Pty Ltd (ABN 23 633 712 295, AFSL 524630).

Latest insights